Nathan James Norman June 12th 2012, 9:11 pm
SPOILER ALERT!!!!! SPOILER ALERT!!!!! SPOILER ALERT!!!!!
------------------------------------------------------
So I just watched the film with a friend from church and it was fantastic.
I think there are two primary questions the film raises:
1. Why did the Engineers create humanity, then want to destroy it?
2. Why did David (the robot) want to infect the crew? (Was he instructed to do so by Weyland? And if so, why?)
After viewing the movie and reading over our fabulously brilliant forum contributors, here's what I think...
1. Why did the Engineers create humanity, then want to destroy it?
As already mentioned, the first alien we see in the film is indeed Prometheus. He sacrifices himself, in order to seed the earth with his genetic material that will, in turn, populate the earth. The other Engineers, once they realize what has happened (eons later?) decide to destroy humanity when they show signs of possessing technology that might soon rival that of the Engineers. (Prometheus gave man fire, and the gods in turn feared the power of man.)
2. Why did David (the robot) want to infect the crew?
At first I thought that he was either under some sort of orders from Weyland, or somehow had special contact with the Engineers (perhaps only through his ability to read the hieroglyphs). But I don't think either of these are the case. As pointed out already, David had a huge fascination with Lawrence of Arabia. So much so, we see him trying to act like Lawrence, and quotes him. Lawrence of Arabia is his worldview and his Bible. Couple that with his desire to rise above his parentage ("isn't every child's dream to kill their parents?"), I think we see his motivation. David's motivation is two-fold:
1. He sees life needing to be like Lawrence of Arabia. Therefore, incompatible creatures need to work together to become greater than they would be seperately. (In the same way that Lawrence united very different peoples, so too, David would become the parent of a new race that he has created through the union of two very different species.)
2. The quote about the fire, "The trick is not minding that it hurts" certainly comes into play. When David the Robot puts a drop of the parasitic fluid on his finger he says "big things come from small beginnings", then infects Holloway. In this scene, I believe, David fully realizes that the joining of these two species will be damaging, harmful, and painful (for the humans) but, "the trick is not minding that it hurts". And so he goes forward with it . . . not realizing that his worldview has some serious errors which lead to destructive result which prove harmful, not helpful to humanity (and himself).
It is interesting that the film ends with the two characters who have the strongest worldviews, surviving. On the one hand we have Elizabeth Shaw, who is a theist trying to uncover the truth of things . . . where ever it leads. Contrast that with David the Robot, whose worldview seeks to conform reality to his ideals, in spite of whatever dire consequences might be had.
I think I still have one lingering question . . . even if my view is wrong. Why did the Engineer(s) point humanity to this planetoid? If this planet was indeed a weapons-depot, then why would the "Prometheus-Engineer" point them there? Or . . . perhaps it was the other Engineers planting the idea of the planetoid into early humanity in order to draw them into this trap, in case they ever did indeed become a technological threat. (But then, why were the Engineers planning on traveling to earth?)
So those are my thoughts. Great stuff. Great movie.
All that AND the theistic characters didn't turn out to be the murderers, psychopaths, or antagonists!